Primo Pizza NY Style

Miguel Fragoso a month ago

Coming from New Jersey and growing up with New Jersey and New York pizza, it can be hard to find really good pizza in North Carolina. We stopped by Primo Pizza last night with the family as we’re getting ready to move from Apex to the Cary area, and this place was a home run. This was easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had in North Carolina. We asked for it to be cooked a little extra done, and it came out perfect. Great crust, great flavor, and exactly what we were looking for. If you’re in the Cary area and haven’t tried Primo Pizza yet, definitely give them a try. You won’t be disappointed.

John Morris 9 months ago

Big guy behind the counter didnt have an attitude. Was very cordial. I ordered a small 2-Topping pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It only took 10 minutes just as he promised. It was clean inside. Nothing flashy but not dirty or rundown as others have said. I think the real problem is "Cary Karens". First of all, anyone from New York will tell you when eating a slice of New York style pizza (thin, foldable) the goal is to eat it as hot and fresh as possible. Not wait an hour after its been cooked and cooled down. Otherwise the grease soaks through the dough and you've got a sopping, dripping, greasy mess. Maybe you should be eating it there in person or within 30 minutes of ordering. I thought the pizza tasted great. You want a pizza that can sit longer, you need to find a thicker crust and go Detroit or Chicago style. I'll definitely be back and so will anyone else that really knows pizza. I was craving something lighter, not so doughy and I got it here.

Mike Moyer 10 months ago

Primo Pizza NY Style in Cary absolutely blew me away! The food is incredible — you can tell everything is freshly made, and the flavors are spot-on. The crust, the sauce, the cheese… everything tastes exactly like classic New York–style pizza done right. The staff was also extremely friendly and welcoming, which made the entire experience even better. It’s one of those places where you feel taken care of from the moment you walk in. I would highly recommend Primo Pizza to anyone looking for amazing, fresh, flavorful pizza in Cary. This place instantly became a favorite!

Don Perez 11 months ago

Best pizza in Cary, hands down their prices are amazing. Their menu have so many options I couldn't believe it. The pizza was delicious and perfectly made the staff takes pride in their job you can tell, that's very hard just to find nowadays by itself the outside area is just a whole vibe hands down I love this place

Robert Dixey 2 years ago

Overall Rating: 4.9/10 A standard local pizza place with a dated yet clean dining area, featuring a straightforward, no-frills service and decent food. Atmosphere: 5.9/10 The restaurant offers a typical local pizza joint vibe with an adequately sized dine-in area. Although the decor is somewhat outdated, the cleanliness and friendly environment contribute positively to the overall atmosphere. Service: 5.5/10 The service is efficient and straightforward, with a self-seating and counter-order setup. Staff members are friendly and ensure that orders are delivered on time, creating a hassle-free dining experience. Although, there was no front room bathroom. Food: Chicken Tenders: 5.9/10 The chicken tenders are noted for their lighter batter, offering a slightly different take from the usual heavily breaded versions. They are fresh and tasty, providing a satisfying meal. Cheese Pizza: 4.1/10 While the pizza is cooked perfectly in terms of toppings and melt, the undercarriage presents a significant drawback. The charred bottom introduces an unwelcome bold, burnt taste that overshadows the otherwise enjoyable cheese and sauce.